The expansion of suckiness
(Psst. Check out Lost EA Traits, my new page. Looks like a couple of my trait ideas were close to what EA had planned after all. Before they cut it for EP#X.)
I enjoyed TS3’s freedom from expansions while it lasted, but all good things come to an end. EA have announced the first TS3 expansion.
I am wholly, WHOLLY unimpressed with a single flaw in this game design.
From the press release:
"[Players will] discover new cities in China, France, and Egypt, and share new stories."
Why am I unimpressed?
Because using real countries is a freaking stupid idea.
I once called this sort of thing a rule of the Sims universe: it’s not Earth! It’s fiction! Suspension of disbelief matters – but obviously not to EA, where money comes ahead of creating a coherent, entertaining game. Did not one person designing this game speak up and point out the ridiculousness of using real country names? Maybe they didn’t want to lose their jobs.
See, the sensible angle would be to describe locations as “European”, “Eastern”, or “Egyptian” (whatever, it’s a dead civilization anyway.) These vacation towns already have unique names – why not market the game with those, like Bon Voyage did?
Seriously, are we to believe that there’s a Sim Taiwan/China and a Sim Israel/Palestine too?
Will these places have real-world languages (hell no), terrible accented gibberish (probably) or just the same Simlish we’re used to (most likely)?
Are the developers trying to shove pro-Yankee imperialism down our throats by having Sims governed by a Leader of the Free World?
Stupid, stupid, stupid. Just the fact that all these questions exist shatter my suspension of disbelief and will ruin any enjoyment I could probably get out of this expansion.
But don’t worry, I’ve got plenty more reasons to hate on World Adventures. The linear, mission-based stories turning the game into less and less of a Wrightian sandbox. The inevitable bugs. Being the harbinger of the upgrade cycle. Cultural stereotyping. My loathing of Vacation and Bon Voyage. The content-stripping (taking content out of the game to plump out future EPs/SPs/the Store).
And the neighbourhood editor that has yet to see the light of day and probably never will. Now that EA is on the expansion wagon, this is the kind of thing that will get pushed to the bottom of the pile and stay there, despite pre-release ‘representations’ that it would be out a few weeks after release.
Really, the editor is the one thing that I’m still ‘following’ TS3 for apart from modding because I will never get attached to premades and premade towns.
Anyway, I’ve never been in this camp before. Before I would eagerly look forward to new expansions. Actually with the Sims, it would be what ‘brought me back to the game’ after not playing it for some time. But I am not going to buy World Adventures. I have no interest in it at all.
September 24th, 2009 at 12:20 am
YES! Thank you. I agree with every single point you brought up. Very well-written post! I haven’t been playing the game, but I have been reading the community forums just to keep up with what’s going on. I miss my sandbox, darnit, and keep hoping against hope that EA will finally release that neighborhood editor. I have a very bad feeling about World Adventures, for all of the reasons you cited. For the first time ever (going back to the days of Sims 1) I am not the least bit excited about an EP, and I doubt I’ll fork over the bucks to buy it. I don’t like the direction they’re heading, not one bit.
September 26th, 2009 at 9:17 pm
I’m willing to give the expansion a chance, but only after a few months have passed so the mods can ripen and the bugs can be sorted out, and only then if it’s at a steeply reduced price!